---
title: "Don’t Just Swap the Motor: Redesign the Work Around AI"
description: Bolting AI onto old processes brings modest gains. Like factories after electricity, associations win when they redesign the work around it and own it.
image: https://bluecypress.io/hubfs/motor_featured_1200x630.png
---

[Skip to main content](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/dont-just-swap-the-motor#main-content)

[![BLUE CYPRESS HORIZON TRANS (1)](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png?width=146&height=38&name=BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png) ![BLUE CYPRESS HORIZON TRANS (1)](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png?width=146&height=38&name=BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png) ![BLUE CYPRESS HORIZON TRANS (1)](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png?width=146&height=38&name=BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png) ![BLUE CYPRESS HORIZON TRANS (1)](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png?width=146&height=38&name=BLUE%20CYPRESS%20HORIZON%20TRANS%20(1).png)](https://bluecypress.io)

- [Show submenu for Explore Solutions Explore Solutions](https://bluecypress.io/explore-solutions) 
    - [All Solutions](https://bluecypress.io/explore-solutions)
    - [Blue Cypress Consulting](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-consulting)
- [Show submenu for Resources Resources](https://bluecypress.io/learn) 
    - [Blog](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog)
- [Show submenu for About About](https://bluecypress.io/about) 
    - [About Blue Cypress](https://bluecypress.io/about)

Open main navigation

Close main navigation

- Show submenu for Explore Solutions Explore Solutions 
  
    - Explore Solutions
    - [Explore Solutions](https://bluecypress.io/explore-solutions)
    - [All Solutions](https://bluecypress.io/explore-solutions)
    - [Blue Cypress Consulting](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-consulting)
- Show submenu for Resources Resources 
  
    - Resources
    - [Resources](https://bluecypress.io/learn)
    - [Blog](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog)
- Show submenu for About About 
  
    - About
    - [About](https://bluecypress.io/about)
    - [About Blue Cypress](https://bluecypress.io/about)
- Search
- [Contact](https://bluecypress.io/contact)

[Contact](https://bluecypress.io/contact)

Search

# Don’t Just Swap the Motor: Redesign the Work Around AI

Picture a factory in the 1890s whose owner has just installed a new electric motor where the steam engine used to sit. It turns the same long shaft down the middle of the building, which drives the same belts and pulleys, which power the same machines, arranged exactly as before. The factory is now electric, but it isn't much more productive.

Many associations are in that factory right now with AI. A chatbot gets bolted onto the website, with the same forms and queues behind it. Staff use a tool that drafts emails a little faster while the process around them stays put. That's a sensible first step, but it isn't where the gains come from. The results it generates are modest, and the temptation is to conclude AI is overhyped. A factory owner in 1900 could have said the same about electricity.

<iframe data-hsv-src="https://play.hubspotvideo.com/v/21417471/id/227812416591" referrerpolicy="origin" sandbox="allow-forms allow-scripts allow-same-origin allow-popups" allow="autoplay; fullscreen;" style="position: absolute !important; width: 100% !important; height: 100% !important; left: 0; top: 0; border: 0 none; pointer-events: initial" title="HubSpot Video" loading="lazy" data-hsv-id="227812416591" data-hsv-style="" data-hsv-width="1920" data-hsv-height="1080" data-hsv-autoplay="false" data-hsv-loop="false" data-hsv-muted="false" data-hsv-hidden-controls="false" data-hsv-full-width="false"></iframe>

## Where productivity gains actually come from

The shaft existed because of steam, since one engine meant one shaft, so machines sat where the shaft could reach them, not where the work needed them. When electric motors arrived, old habits held and the shaft stayed. By the end of the 19th century, motors supplied under 5% of the mechanical power in American factories, and where they had arrived, they often just turned the old shaft. Despite the new technology, manufacturing productivity growth was sluggish from the late 19th through the early 20th century.

The payoff came in the 1920s, roughly four decades after electricity was commercialized, when factories started putting a small motor on every machine. With no central shaft, factories could be laid out around the flow of work. During that decade, productivity growth in US manufacturing jumped by about five percentage points over the decade before. The economic historian Paul David, who told this story in a 1990 paper called "The Dynamo and the Computer," concluded that the gains didn't arrive with the new technology but when people redesigned the work around it.

His title pointed back to 1987, when the economist Robert Solow had written, "You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics." Offices were running the same play, putting capable PCs on desks and using them as terminals for the mainframe, the old green-on-black screens that did no computing of their own. US productivity growth picked up in the late 1990s, and Federal Reserve economists credited information technology for most of the rise. I'd argue the gains came when companies stopped using PCs as green screens and rebuilt their work around them.

## What a redesign looks like

Take a hypothetical professional society with 15,000 credentialed members who renew every three years by documenting their continuing education.

The motor-swap version adds a chatbot that answers "how many credits do I need?" That helps, but nothing else changes. Members upload certificates in the final month, and three staff members check each one by hand, chase missing documents by email, and key the results into the AMS. Every cycle ends in a crunch, and some members lapse because they found out too late that they were a few credits short.

The redesigned version starts by asking how renewal would work if the society built it today. An AI agent reviews each submission as it arrives, checks it against the society's rules, and records what qualifies. Anything it can't confirm goes to a staff member, who makes the call. Partway through the cycle, every member hears exactly where they stand: you have 22 of your 30 credits, two of your sessions don't count toward the ethics requirement, and here are three upcoming courses that do. Submissions spread out, the crunch shrinks, and staff spend their time on exceptions, appeals, and the conversations that need a person.

## This time, the motor keeps changing

A century ago, once a factory rebuilt its floor plan around electric motors, the hard part was done, and no one expected to replace the motors every year.

With AI it's the reverse, because the model is the motor and the models improve every few months. No one can predict whose model will lead next quarter (much less next year), so expect to swap the motor often. What lasts is the floor plan, meaning your rules, your institutional knowledge, the workflows you redesigned, and the record of every decision. In the renewal example, that's the credit rules the agent checks against, the hand-off to staff, and the history of every ruling. That's where the effort went, and it's the part you want to own.

If that floor plan [lives inside one vendor's platform](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/backing-up-the-truck), you've rented your new factory. You can rebuild the work, but you often can't take it with you (or if you can, it's a pain), and the landlord decides which motors you can plug in. If you own it, changing models becomes cheap and routine.

That is the thinking behind [MemberJunction](https://memberjunction.org), the platform Blue Cypress builds so associations can keep their data, agents, and workflows in their own environment and plug in whichever models make sense. That said, MemberJunction is not the only way to get there, and the principle matters more than any product.

## Questions worth asking now

- If we built our most painful process from scratch today, with the tools now available, what would it look like?
- Where are we adding new technology to an old process instead of changing the process?
- What work do our staff do only because our systems were built for an older way of working?
- Is the knowledge that runs our processes written down, or does it live in a few people's heads?
- If we switched vendors or models next year, what would we keep, and what would we lose? How hard would switching be?

Factories took about forty years to figure this out, and offices took more than a decade to do the same with personal computers. Associations don't have to take that long, and this time the floor plan is something they can own.

For more on ownership and control in the AI era, read the Blue Cypress series on sovereign AI, starting with [Who Would You Trust With Your Association's Data?](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/who-would-you-trust-with-your-associations-data) and [Backing Up the Truck](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/backing-up-the-truck).

### Sources

- Robert M. Solow, "We'd Better Watch Out," *New York Times Book Review*, July 12, 1987, p. 36.
- Paul A. David, "The Dynamo and the Computer: An Historical Perspective on the Modern Productivity Paradox," *American Economic Review* 80, no. 2 (May 1990): 355-361.
- Stephen D. Oliner and Daniel E. Sichel, "[The Resurgence of Growth in the Late 1990s: Is Information Technology the Story?](https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.14.4.3)" *Journal of Economic Perspectives* 14, no. 4 (2000): 3-22.

---

## Join us live: Sovereign AI webinar

Amith Nagarajan goes deeper on owning your AI foundation in a free webinar on **Tuesday, December 8 at 12 PM ET**, with time for your questions. [**Register free →**](https://sidecar.ai/sovereign-ai-webinar-registration?utm_source=bluecypress&utm_medium=blog&utm_campaign=sovereign-ai-dec8&utm_content=motor-blog)

Want more like this? Get what we're learning about AI, every week. [**Subscribe to the Blue Cypress newsletter →**](https://pages.rasa.io/signup/807526a0-ab58-cf1f-66ce-adb17313a2e7?utm_source=signup)

Tags:

![John Huisman](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/john_h_headshot.png?width=120&height=120&name=john_h_headshot.png)

**[John Huisman](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/author/john-huisman)**  
 Nov 17, 2026, 9:45:49 PM

 John Huisman is the Chief Operating Officer of Blue Cypress, where he oversees eight operating companies across product, go-to-market and operations. He previously was an Associate Partner at Bain & Company, focused on digital transformation and generative AI.

[Follow me on LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/johnehuisman/)

## Related Articles

## Blue Cypress

<https://bluecypress.io/>[![Blue Cypress](https://bluecypress.io/hs-fs/hubfs/blue-cypress-logo-white.png?width=289&height=75&name=blue-cypress-logo-white.png)](https://bluecypress.io/)

6221 S. Claiborne Ave, Suite 587  
New Orleans, LA 70125

Solutions

- [Explore solutions](https://bluecypress.io/explore-solutions)
- [Blue Cypress Consulting](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-consulting)
- [Family of companies](https://bluecypress.io/family-of-companies)
- [Innovate with us](https://bluecypress.io/innovate-with-us)

Company

- [About](https://bluecypress.io/about)
- [Learn](https://bluecypress.io/learn)
- [Blog](https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog)
- [Contact](https://bluecypress.io/contact)

Newsletter

## Get what we are learning about AI, every week.

Association AI, in plain language. No pitch, and you can unsubscribe whenever you like.

[Sign up for the newsletter (opens in a new tab)](https://pages.rasa.io/signup/807526a0-ab58-cf1f-66ce-adb17313a2e7?utm_source=signup)

© 2026 Blue Cypress. All rights reserved. [Privacy Policy](https://bluecypress.io/privacy-policy) [LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)](https://www.linkedin.com/company/blue-cypress)

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "John Huisman",
    "url" : "https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/author/john-huisman"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-18T17:22:17.162Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-18T02:45:49.000Z",
  "headline" : "Don’t Just Swap the Motor: Redesign the Work Around AI",
  "image" : [ "https://bluecypress.io/hubfs/motor_featured_1200x630.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://bluecypress.io/blue-cypress-blog/dont-just-swap-the-motor",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://bluecypress.io/hubfs/Mark%20Only.png"
    },
    "name" : "Blue Cypress"
  }
}
```

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "VideoObject",
  "contentUrl" : "https://21417471.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/21417471/video_assets/227802924920/inherited/web_optimized.mp4",
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-18T01:55:20.425Z",
  "duration" : "PT3M47S",
  "height" : 1080,
  "name" : "dont-just-swap-the-motor-email-1",
  "thumbnailUrl" : "https://21417471.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hubfs/21417471/dont-just-swap-the-motor-email-1.mp4/medium.jpg",
  "uploadDate" : "2026-11-18T01:55:20.422Z",
  "width" : 1920
}
```